Angel and venture investors in startups and early-stage companies frequently have the option to determine the extent to which they intend to contribute intellectual capital, beyond their financial commitments. “Value-added” private venture investors often lend their business skills, resources and rolodex to their interests, helping the company solve tough problems, prioritize objectives, build a great team and even seek out strategic partners and potential customers.
Equally compelling to private venture investors is the ability to influence the terms of engagement of their capital in a manner that increases the opportunity for a favorable investment outcome. Unlike conventional public investment vehicles and most alternative products such as hedge funds, the investment terms for private venture investments are generally negotiable…depending on the size of the contemplated investment and stage of the company and the funding history.
Evaluate—Negotiate–Allocate
Between due diligence and the investment decision is the opportunity to influence and negotiate investment terms in a manner that increases the probability of a positive asymmetric outcome. It surprises me when angel allocators, particularly lead investors in a seed round, simply accept the offering terms of a private venture without fully leveraging their currency to negotiate the best deal for their capital. Startup capital for new ventures is scarce today relative to the halcyon days of the 1990’s. That tilts the advantage in favor of capital and provides early-stage venture investors with an opportunity to materially improve upon their position.
Angel round investors are a unique breed. They take on startups at the riskier seed stage (in pursuit of higher-multiple exits) at a point where venture capital firms will typically not engage. VCs and institutional investors are more apt to require some evidence of progress with a startup…whether with regards to financing, product development, a proven business model or market traction. Yet that does not prevent VCs from coming to the table with their own terms for a Series A financing.
On the other hand, angels too often let the entrepreneur set the terms for the seed and bridge financing rounds.
So, which provisions in an angel round’s term sheet are generally negotiable? All of them.
I am humored by entrepreneurs who describe their terms as being “market”. Because there is no market without the angel’s capital, and that means that valuation, liquidation preference, anti-dilution protection, dividends, various protective provisions, board composition and even the vesting of the founder’s stock can and often should be subject to negotiation…particularly in a smaller financing round.
Each of these terms may have a critical influence on the outcome of an early-stage investment, but valuation is arguably the most difficult for angel investors to negotiate as there is little meaningful company history to assess…rather, merely a vision around an idea, a market and a management team, and perhaps a business plan.
The “market” (of angel investors and entrepreneurs) has responded to this quandary by predominantly relying upon Convertible Notes to fund seed-stage companies. Rather than dickering endlessly about the present value of a future uncertainty, angels and entrepreneurs agree to lend their capital to the new venture in the form of a note (often secured with some form of collateral and offering a dividend) and agree to convert their debt to equity at the price set in the subsequent round of financing.
The theory is at that point in the future, much more will be known about the business, market, competition and opportunity and that it will be easier to agree on a valuation.
Consequently, Convertible Notes have become the primary template for seeding young companies and providing “bridge” financing from the concept stage to a larger, subsequent financing round.
Early-stage investors should engage the growing universe of online content that speaks to best practices, suggested deal terms and negotiation tips for investors in early-stage ventures. Most critically, tyro angels should engage a securities attorney with ample experience in private venture financings to advise them on term sheet negotiation.
In Woody Alan’s 1994 crime-comedy Bullets Over Broadway, the gangster-financier played by Chazz Palminteri exploited his angel status by casting his girlfriend in a lead role and rewriting the play’s script.
In early-stage financings artful angels should always consider opportunities to leverage their currency to rewrite the script of the bridge note and positively influence their investment’s ultimate optionality and outcome.
Album: Script of the Bridge, The Chameleons, 1983
